Wednesday, May 17, 2006

Story on Major General John Batiste

From The Wall Street Journal, here's a story from a few days back about Major General John Batiste, one of the retired generals calling for Rumsfeld to step down:
Military officers, like Gen. Batiste, are constantly reminded that their role is to advise civilian leaders and execute their orders -- even if they disagree with them.

Now he was stepping way out of that culture. Gen. Batiste and his wife, the children of career military officers, had spent their entire lives in the Army. He fought in the first Gulf War, led a brigade into Bosnia, and in 2004 commanded 22,000 troops in Iraq, losing more than 150 soldiers.

"I was shocked at where I was," he says. "I had spent the last 31 years of my life defending our great Constitution." Over the course of the war in Iraq he says he saw troop shortages that allowed a deadly insurgency to take root, felt politics were put ahead of hard-won military lessons and was haunted by the regretful words of a top general in Vietnam.

The war in Iraq should have been a decisive victory for the U.S., Gen. Batiste told himself, as he paced in the parking garage. He blamed Mr. Rumsfeld for his "contemptuous attitude" and his "refusal to take sound military advice." As he got into his car to drive home, he recalls thinking: "If I don't speak out, who the hell else will?"

Before Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld drag us into more of their costly adventures, many more Americans need to speak out.

2 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

It seems that when I speak nobody listens. Emm maybe I need to go back to Toastmasters?

10:51 PM  
Blogger Poechewe said...

Kmilyun, my feeling is that if a person speaks out just once, that person has done far most than most other people. Your blog means you already are speaking out.

Bush's falling poll numbers suggest people are listening to those who believe Bush has made many costly blunders and has done things that can't be justified.

If you're asking if there's more that you can do, the answer is yes. Letters to the editor, letters to members of Congress, comments on open forums (AOL's forums, for example, are open to nonmembers) and hunting for useful information that other bloggers can use (including this one) are good things to do. You can also, if you wish, publicize your blog more. You don't talk politics all the time and for some people that actually makes you more credible.

But I'm a believer in no guilt. You've already been doing your share.

4:36 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home